
Linguistic Minority
Back when I was in 7th grade, I knew the answer to almost every question our science teacher asked, and I remember almost nothing from those lessons. What I do remember, is the day a boy at the back asked why we can't see stars during the day, since the Sun is a star too. The teacher told us to find out before the next class. Half of us genuinely did.
The answer turned out to be one boring paragraph in our textbook. What wasn't boring was the two days we spent not knowing it.
Many of us figure out pretty early that the safe thing in class is to say the right answer or say nothing. If you get it wrong, the teacher sighs or you hear a giggle from someone in the class, so you stop guessing. By the time students get to CBSE secondary education, a lot of them have learned to watch the teacher's face before they answer. If she nods, they keep going. If she frowns, they change their answer. It works for marks, but it isn't really thinking.
It starts a lot earlier than people think. Spend ten minutes around a four-year-old at any pre-primary school and all you will hear is “why, why, why?” “Why is the road wet?”, “Why does the fan spin?”, “Why can't I eat the crayon?”. By Class 8, most of us stop asking. A primary school that lets kids keep asking, even when it slows the lesson down, is doing something harder than finishing the syllabus on time.
A lot of this depends on the teacher. People talk about teaching methodology in education like it's complicated, but I think it comes down to what happens when a student gets something wrong. If the teacher sighs, students stop trying. If she says "Interesting…let's find out why," they keep going. Small things help. We should try a problem before explaining it. Say "good question" when someone diverts from the lesson. If you don't know something, just say so. Students notice, and they relax.
Exams still matter and I am definitely not encouraging to ignore them, but curious students usually do fine anyway, because they understand the chapter instead of just memorising it. If you know why a formula works, you can work it out again when you forget it. If you only memorised it, you are left with a blank face.
Whenever we got group projects, I wanted the classmate with the odd questions, not the one with the right answers. The person with the right answers finished in ten minutes. The other one made the project making experience, memorable.
So, if you are choosing a CBSE school that Pune has to offer, even one calling itself the Best CBSE School in Pune, don't just read the results board outside the gate. Sit in their class and just see. See how many questions the students ask and see how the teacher reacts. That will always show you more than any brochure.
